I have not lived in Philadelphia for 20 years, but I am nonetheless a loyal son. There is only one sort of Philly cheese steak, the kind you find in the city--not the California version--with tomatoes and lettuce. I love soft pretzels and Tastykakes. I became a lover of history being born in a city with so much of it, and I am an avid sports fan.
I follow the Flyers, but not a hockey fan. I grew up watching the Sixers, but have to admit that I have also become a Suns fan. I am passionate about the Eagles, but have a dual allegiance to the Niners. While I have flirted with the Braves and Giants, I have always kept my eye on the Phillies
This weekend and couple of days have been a series of highs and low. it is a tale of two teams and the overriding theme is leadership--one team has it and the other one doesn't.
i watched in horror as the eagles lost to the Oakland Raiders--a team that was supposedly in such disarray that made this game an easy win. I admit that I counted this game a win before the played the game, but what I saw on Sunday afternoon was a travesty--yet it one that has repeated itself time and time again.
The coaching sucked and so did the quarterback, and with both it has been a love hate relationship. I have been ambivalent and even apathetic towards Andy Reid while building distaste for how he and Marty Morningwig calls the game. Of course, I love it when they win, but it is during the tough games that we see his true colors, the inability to adapt and make adjustments in their play calling.
My beef with Donovan McNabb is for two reasons, first, I am tired of passes thrown in the dirt, and second, he is not a leader.
Playing the position of quarterback does not make you a leader. While he is among the best quarterbacks in the last ten years, I refrain from putting him in the upper echelons of great and legendary quarterbacks.
He lacks what separates a good quarterback from a great quarterback, such as the inability to rally the troops. It is easy to rally when things are going good, but when the game is tough and you’re getting ass kicked by the other team, you have to reach down deep is what makes a good quarterback great.
Secondly, he takes no responsibility for the action of his team. For better or for worse, the quarterback is the primary high profile player on a team. Shouldering the team on your back and will them to go all out for you--instilling confidence in you and your abilities and the abilities in themselves is what makes a good quarterback great. It also includes getting in the face of our players when they’re not playing well and encouraging them to play better. It does not include huffing and puffing when things do not go well.
Thirdly, he cannot take the team the distance on the final drive. Once again, McNabb has proven that he cannot win given the time and space to do it when it matters most. He could not do it in the Super bowl versus the Patriots when you had the best Eagle team ever, and he could not do it on Sunday when the Eagles had a better talent-laden offense than the Raider defense. However, I am aware that the offensive line had holes—but I look to the coaches for that. Moreover, the thing that bothers me most of all, and have since Donovan became an Eagle is his lack of passing accuracy when it matters. If I see, another pass thrown in the dirt, it will be the death of me.
When I see Donovan huffing and puffing, I look at the coach and see similar disposition. I wonder why is he not admonishing his best player to take charge of the team and I can only shake my head in disgust. I think Reid let the wrong player go--instead of Brian Dawkins.
I have few words for Andy Reid and few are of praise. Yes, he is the winningest coach Philadelphia has ever had, which is a testament to the ability of the Eagles to amass talent, and acknowledge that he does rank as one of the better coaches in the league.
But as I say of Donovan McNabb being one of the better quarterbacks in the last ten years but not among the best, I say of Andy Reid as a coach. To take a team to the NFC Championship game 6 times is a sign of good coaching, but he only one of those to reach the Super Bowl when he should/could have one more.
I cannot put Reid in the ranks with Bill Cowher, Bill Belicheck, and Tony Dungy because of what happened this past Sunday with the Raiders has become all too familiar with the Eagles.
The inability to adjust the game plan to the conditions on the field, the inability to manage the clock properly, and the inability to prepare your team to play to its potential every game—no matter the opponent.
Five years ago, I would have a different conversation regarding my Eagles. It would have been much like what I have to say about the Phillies with one exception…
then there is the Phillies…
You gotta love this team.
I was lukewarm on them last year until they made their run into the playoffs and watched the World Series entirely for the first time in years. I followed them better this year as I see a team that could repeat their 2008 performance if they keep the core unit together—which they did.
In the Fightin’ Phils, I see a team that does not give up—even when it looks like a sure loss. I am not just talking about last night’s game, which had me on a rollercoaster of emotion, but this is what they have done all year long.
And to finally see Brad Lidge step back up…
This is definitely a tale of two teams.
Usually, when the NFL season comes along, the Philadelphia Eagles dominate the headlines and the attention of the sports fan, but right now—we got nothing but love for our Phillies.
I remember the 1980 World Series, Steve Carlton, Tug McGraw, Pete Rose, and Mike Schmidt. As a kid I’d watch Mike’s milk commercials and wanted a refrigerator full of milk just like Mike had on that commercial. He still is my all time favorite #20 (Brian Dawkins come in a close second), and third baseman.
I watched last year’s wet series wondering if Tampa Bay was going to pull it out from under them. Now, I have a simmering confidence and pride from my Phillies.
And a impatient frustration for my Eagles.
Leadership is the key.
You can tell that the team is steadied by its manager, Charlie Manuel and is spurned on by each other to continue to play better and better. This team has a no quit and it is not over until it is over mentality.
Teams know that it takes 27 outs to beat the Phillies, just ask the L.A. Dodgers.
Today’s sports climate in Philadelphia is a lesson in leadership. One team has it and the other one does not.
In Charlie Manuel, you have a team leader that knows how to adapt and change his strategy to maximize the talent of his players. He trusts his players and believes in them—which allows them to trust and believe in him and in one another.
While I may not agree with all of Manuel’s moves, I cannot deny the results in the last three years.
Players step up and be counted and some prove their worth.
One of the most unsung heroes is Ryan Howard. The man does not get enough credit for what he does and he continues to perform by tying Lou Gehrig’s record of 8 straight RBI games in the post season.
The Bullpen has been phenomenal with Chan Ho Park and Brad Lidge leading the charge to rack of strike after strikes.
All 25 players had a role in this run, from the pinch hitters to the slugger, Ryan Howard, and the clench hitting of Shane Victorino and Jimmy Rollins.
And you can't forget Senor Octubre, Catcher Carlos Ruiz, the field general of this team.
Let’s go Phils.
V.